Patient-specific collision zones for 4π trajectory optimized radiation therapy.

The 4π methodology determines optimized noncoplanar subarcs for stereotactic radiation therapy that minimize dose to organs-at-risk. Every combination of treatment angle is examined, but some angles are not appropriate as a collision would occur between the gantry and the couch or the gantry and the patient. Those combinations of couch and gantry angles are referred to as collision zones. A major barrier to applying 4π to stereotactic body radiation therapy (SBRT) is the unknown shape of the collision zones, which are significant as patients take up a large volume within the 4π sphere. This study presents a system that determines patient-specific collision zones, without additional clinical steps, to enable safe and deliverable noncoplanar treatment trajectories for SBRT patients. To augment patient's computed tomography (CT) scan, full body scans of patients in treatment position were acquired using an optical scanner. A library of a priori scans (N = 25) was created. Based on the patients' treatment position and their body dimensions, a library scan is selected and registered to the CT scan of the patient. Next, a model of the couch and immobilization equipment is added to the patient model. This results in a patient model that is then aligned with a model of the treatment LINAC in a "virtual treatment room," where both components can be rotated to test for collisions. To test the collision detection algorithm, an end-to-end test was performed using a cranial phantom. The registration algorithm was tested by comparing the registered patient collision zones to those generated by using the patient's matching scan. The collision detection algorithm was found to have a 97.80% accuracy, a 99.99% sensitivity, and a 99.99% negative predictive value (NPV). Analysis of the registration algorithm determined that a 6 cm buffer was required to achieve a 99.65% mean sensitivity, where a sensitivity of unity is considered to be a requirement for safe treatment delivery. With a 6 cm buffer, the mean accuracy was 86.70% and the mean NPV was 99.33%. Our method of determining patient-specific collision zones can be accomplished with minimal user intervention based on an a priori library of body surface scans, thus enabling the safe application of 4π SBRT.

Northway C ，Lincoln JD ，Little B ，Syme A ，Thomas CG ... -  《-》

Development and clinical implementation of eclipse scripting-based automated patient-specific collision avoidance software.

Increased use of Linac-based stereotactic radiosurgery (SRS), which requires highly noncoplanar gantry trajectories, necessitates the development of efficient and accurate methods of collision detection during the treatment planning process. This work outlines the development and clinical implementation of a patient-specific computed tomography (CT) contour-based solution that utilizes Eclipse Scripting to ensure maximum integration with clinical workflow. The collision detection application uses triangle mesh structures of the gantry and couch, in addition to the body contour of the patient taken during CT simulation, to virtually simulate patient treatments. Collision detection is performed using Binary Tree Hierarchy detection methods. Algorithm accuracy was first validated for simple cuboidal geometry using a calibration phantom and then extended to an anthropomorphic phantom simulation by comparing the measured minimum distance between structures to the predicted minimum distance for all allowable orientations. The collision space was tested at couch angles every 15° from 90 to 270 with the gantry incremented by 5° through the maximum trajectory. Receiver operating characteristic curve analysis was used to assess algorithm sensitivity and accuracy for predicting collision events. Following extensive validation, the application was implemented clinically for all SRS patients. The application was able to predict minimum distances between structures to within 3 cm. A safety margin of 1.5 cm was sufficient to achieve 100% sensitivity for all test cases. Accuracy obtained was 94.2% with the 5 cm clinical safety margin with 100% true positive collision detection. A total of 88 noncoplanar SRS patients have been currently tested using the application with one collision detected and no undetected collisions occurring. The average time for collision testing per patient was 2 min 58 s. A collision detection application utilizing patient CT contours was developed and successfully clinically implemented. This application allows collisions to be detected early during the planning process, avoiding patient delays and unnecessary resource utilization if detected during delivery.

Mann TD ，Ploquin NP ，Gill WR ，Thind KS ... -  《Journal of Applied Clinical Medical Physics》

Choreographing couch and collimator in volumetric modulated arc therapy.

To design and optimize trajectory-based, noncoplanar subarcs for volumetric modulated arc therapy (VMAT) deliverable on both Varian TrueBEAM system and traditional accelerators; and to investigate their potential advantages for treating central nervous system (CNS) tumors. To guide the computerized selection of beam trajectories consisting of simultaneous couch, gantry, and collimator motion, a score function was implemented to estimate the geometric overlap between targets and organs at risk for each couch/gantry angle combination. An initial set of beam orientations is obtained as a function of couch and gantry angle, according to a minimum search of the score function excluding zones of collision. This set is grouped into multiple continuous and extended subarcs subject to mechanical limitations using a hierarchical clustering algorithm. After determination of couch/gantry trajectories, a principal component analysis finds the collimator angle at each beam orientation that minimizes residual target-organ at risk overlaps. An in-house VMAT optimization algorithm determines the optimal multileaf collimator position and monitor units for control points within each subarc. A retrospective study of 10 CNS patients compares the proposed method of VMAT trajectory with dynamic gantry, leaves, couch, and collimator motion (Tra-VMAT); a standard noncoplanar VMAT with no couch/collimator motion within subarcs (Std-VMAT); and noncoplanar intensity-modulated radiotherapy (IMRT) plans that were clinically used. Tra-VMAT provided improved target dose conformality and lowered maximum dose to brainstem, optic nerves, and chiasm by 7.7%, 1.1%, 2.3%, and 1.7%, respectively, compared with Std-VMAT. Tra-VMAT provided higher planning target volume minimum dose and reduced maximum dose to chiasm, optic nerves, and cochlea by 6.2%, 1.3%, 6.3%, and 8.4%, respectively, and reduced cochlea mean dose by 8.7%, compared with IMRT. Tra-VMAT averaged beam-on time was comparable to Std-VMAT but significantly (45%) less than IMRT. Optimized couch, gantry, and collimator trajectories may be integrated into VMAT with improved mechanical flexibility and may provide better dosimetric properties and improved efficiency in the treatment of CNS tumors.

Yang Y ，Zhang P ，Happersett L ，Xiong J ，Yang J ，Chan M ，Beal K ，Mageras G ，Hunt M ... -  《-》

The development and verification of a highly accurate collision prediction model for automated noncoplanar plan delivery.

Yu VY ，Tran A ，Nguyen D ，Cao M ，Ruan D ，Low DA ，Sheng K ... -  《-》

4π non-coplanar liver SBRT: a novel delivery technique.

To improve the quality of liver stereotactic body radiation therapy (SBRT) treatments, a novel 4π framework was developed with accompanying algorithms to optimize non-coplanar beam orientations and fluences. The dose optimization is performed on a patient-specific deliverable beam geometry solution space, parameterized with patient and linear accelerator gantry orientations. Beams causing collision between the gantry and the couch or patient were eliminated by simulating all beam orientations using a precise computer assisted design model of the linear accelerator and a human subject. Integrated beam orientation and fluence map optimizations were performed on remaining beams using a greedy column generation method. Testing of the new method was performed on 10 liver SBRT cases previously treated with 50 to 60 Gy in 5 fractions using volumetric modulated arc therapy (VMAT). For each patient, both 14 and 22 non-coplanar fields were selected and optimized to meet the objective of ≥95% of the planning target volume (PTV) covered by 100% of the prescription dose. Doses to organs at risk, normal liver volumes receiving <15 Gy, integral dose, and 50% dose spillage volumes were compared against the delivered clinical VMAT plans. Compared with the VMAT plans, the 4π plans yielded reduced 50% dose spillage volume and integral dose by 22% (range 10%-40%) and 19% (range 13%-26%), respectively. The mean normal liver volume receiving <15 Gy was increased by 51 cc (range 21-107 cc) with a 31% reduction of the mean normal liver dose. Mean doses to the left kidney and right kidney and maximum doses to the stomach and spinal cord were on average reduced by 70%, 51%, 67%, and 64% (P≤.05). This novel 4π non-coplanar radiation delivery technique significantly improved dose gradient, reduced high dose spillage, and improved organ at risk sparing compared with state of the art VMAT plans.

Dong P ，Lee P ，Ruan D ，Long T ，Romeijn E ，Yang Y ，Low D ，Kupelian P ，Sheng K ... -  《-》