Evaluation of the impact of Illumina error correction tools on de novo genome assembly.

Recently, many standalone applications have been proposed to correct sequencing errors in Illumina data. The key idea is that downstream analysis tools such as de novo genome assemblers benefit from a reduced error rate in the input data. Surprisingly, a systematic validation of this assumption using state-of-the-art assembly methods is lacking, even for recently published methods. For twelve recent Illumina error correction tools (EC tools) we evaluated both their ability to correct sequencing errors and their ability to improve de novo genome assembly in terms of contig size and accuracy. We confirm that most EC tools reduce the number of errors in sequencing data without introducing many new errors. However, we found that many EC tools suffer from poor performance in certain sequence contexts such as regions with low coverage or regions that contain short repeated or low-complexity sequences. Reads overlapping such regions are often ill-corrected in an inconsistent manner, leading to breakpoints in the resulting assemblies that are not present in assemblies obtained from uncorrected data. Resolving this systematic flaw in future EC tools could greatly improve the applicability of such tools.

Heydari M ，Miclotte G ，Demeester P ，Van de Peer Y ，Fostier J ... -  《BMC BIOINFORMATICS》

Illumina error correction near highly repetitive DNA regions improves de novo genome assembly.

Several standalone error correction tools have been proposed to correct sequencing errors in Illumina data in order to facilitate de novo genome assembly. However, in a recent survey, we showed that state-of-the-art assemblers often did not benefit from this pre-correction step. We found that many error correction tools introduce new errors in reads that overlap highly repetitive DNA regions such as low-complexity patterns or short homopolymers, ultimately leading to a more fragmented assembly. We propose BrownieCorrector, an error correction tool for Illumina sequencing data that focuses on the correction of only those reads that overlap short DNA patterns that are highly repetitive in the genome. BrownieCorrector extracts all reads that contain such a pattern and clusters them into different groups using a community detection algorithm that takes into account both the sequence similarity between overlapping reads and their respective paired-end reads. Each cluster holds reads that originate from the same genomic region and hence each cluster can be corrected individually, thus providing a consistent correction for all reads within that cluster. BrownieCorrector is benchmarked using six real Illumina datasets for different eukaryotic genomes. The prior use of BrownieCorrector improves assembly results over the use of uncorrected reads in all cases. In comparison with other error correction tools, BrownieCorrector leads to the best assembly results in most cases even though less than 2% of the reads within a dataset are corrected. Additionally, we investigate the impact of error correction on hybrid assembly where the corrected Illumina reads are supplemented with PacBio data. Our results confirm that BrownieCorrector improves the quality of hybrid genome assembly as well. BrownieCorrector is written in standard C++11 and released under GPL license. BrownieCorrector relies on multithreading to take advantage of multi-core/multi-CPU systems. The source code is available at https://github.com/biointec/browniecorrector .

Heydari M ，Miclotte G ，Van de Peer Y ，Fostier J ... -  《BMC BIOINFORMATICS》

An efficient error correction algorithm using FM-index.

High-throughput sequencing offers higher throughput and lower cost for sequencing a genome. However, sequencing errors, including mismatches and indels, may be produced during sequencing. Because, errors may reduce the accuracy of subsequent de novo assembly, error correction is necessary prior to assembly. However, existing correction methods still face trade-offs among correction power, accuracy, and speed. We develop a novel overlap-based error correction algorithm using FM-index (called FMOE). FMOE first identifies overlapping reads by aligning a query read simultaneously against multiple reads compressed by FM-index. Subsequently, sequencing errors are corrected by k-mer voting from overlapping reads only. The experimental results indicate that FMOE has highest correction power with comparable accuracy and speed. Our algorithm performs better in long-read than short-read datasets when compared with others. The assembly results indicated different algorithms has its own strength and weakness, whereas FMOE is good for long or good-quality reads. FMOE is freely available at https://github.com/ythuang0522/FMOC .

Huang YT ，Huang YW 《BMC BIOINFORMATICS》

QuorUM: An Error Corrector for Illumina Reads.

Illumina Sequencing data can provide high coverage of a genome by relatively short (most often 100 bp to 150 bp) reads at a low cost. Even with low (advertised 1%) error rate, 100 × coverage Illumina data on average has an error in some read at every base in the genome. These errors make handling the data more complicated because they result in a large number of low-count erroneous k-mers in the reads. However, there is enough information in the reads to correct most of the sequencing errors, thus making subsequent use of the data (e.g. for mapping or assembly) easier. Here we use the term "error correction" to denote the reduction in errors due to both changes in individual bases and trimming of unusable sequence. We developed an error correction software called QuorUM. QuorUM is mainly aimed at error correcting Illumina reads for subsequent assembly. It is designed around the novel idea of minimizing the number of distinct erroneous k-mers in the output reads and preserving the most true k-mers, and we introduce a composite statistic π that measures how successful we are at achieving this dual goal. We evaluate the performance of QuorUM by correcting actual Illumina reads from genomes for which a reference assembly is available. We produce trimmed and error-corrected reads that result in assemblies with longer contigs and fewer errors. We compared QuorUM against several published error correctors and found that it is the best performer in most metrics we use. QuorUM is efficiently implemented making use of current multi-core computing architectures and it is suitable for large data sets (1 billion bases checked and corrected per day per core). We also demonstrate that a third-party assembler (SOAPdenovo) benefits significantly from using QuorUM error-corrected reads. QuorUM error corrected reads result in a factor of 1.1 to 4 improvement in N50 contig size compared to using the original reads with SOAPdenovo for the data sets investigated. QuorUM is distributed as an independent software package and as a module of the MaSuRCA assembly software. Both are available under the GPL open source license at http://www.genome.umd.edu. gmarcais@umd.edu.

Marçais G ，Yorke JA ，Zimin A 《PLoS One》

Simultaneous compression of multiple error-corrected short-read sets for faster data transmission and better de novo assemblies.

Next-Generation Sequencing has produced incredible amounts of short-reads sequence data for de novo genome assembly over the last decades. For efficient transmission of these huge datasets, high-performance compression algorithms have been intensively studied. As both the de novo assembly and error correction methods utilize the overlaps between reads data, a concern is that the will the sequencing errors bring up negative effects on genome assemblies also affect the compression of the NGS data. This work addresses two problems: how current error correction algorithms can enable the compression algorithms to make the sequence data much more compact, and whether the sequence-modified reads by the error-correction algorithms will lead to quality improvement for de novo contig assembly. As multiple sets of short reads are often produced by a single biomedical project in practice, we propose a graph-based method to reorder the files in the collection of multiple sets and then compress them simultaneously for a further compression improvement after error correction. We use examples to illustrate that accurate error correction algorithms can significantly reduce the number of mismatched nucleotides in the reference-free compression, hence can greatly improve the compression performance. Extensive test on practical collections of multiple short-read sets does confirm that the compression performance on the error-corrected data (with unchanged size) significantly outperforms that on the original data, and that the file reordering idea contributes furthermore. The error correction on the original reads has also resulted in quality improvements of the genome assemblies, sometimes remarkably. However, it is still an open question that how to combine appropriate error correction methods with an assembly algorithm so that the assembly performance can be always significantly improved.

Tang T ，Hutvagner G ，Wang W ，Li J ... -  《-》