Diagnostic Value of Sarcopenia Computed Tomography Metrics for Older Patients with or without Cancers with Gastrointestinal Disorders.
The diagnostic utility of poor body composition measures in sarcopenia remains unclear. We hypothesize that the skeletal muscle gauge [combination of skeletal muscle index (SMI) and skeletal muscle density (SMD); SMG = SMI × SMD] would have significant diagnostic and predictive value in certain muscle regions and populations.
Prospective cross-sectional study.
We examined inpatients age ≥60 years with or without cancer and with gastrointestinal disorders.
We used computed tomography (CT) image metrics in the 12th thoracic (T12), third lumbar (L3), erector spinae muscle (ESM), and psoas muscle (PM) regions to establish correlations with the 2019 Asian Working Group for Sarcopenia Consensus and used receiver operating characteristic area under the curve (AUC) to compare differences between metrics. Associations between CT metrics and mortality were reported as relative risk after adjustments.
We evaluated 385 patients (median age, 69.0 years; 60.8% men) and found consistent trends in cancer (49.6%) and noncancer (50.4%) cohorts. SMG had a stronger correlation with muscle mass than SMD [mean rho: 0.68 (range, 0.59‒0.73) vs 0.39 (range, 0.28‒0.48); all P < .01] in T12, L3, and PM regions and a stronger correlation with muscle function than SMI [mean rho: 0.60 (range, 0.50‒0.77) vs 0.36 (range, 0.22‒0.58); all P < .05] in T12, ESM, and L3 regions. SMG outperformed SMI in diagnostic accuracy in all regions, particularly for L3 (AUC: 0.87‒0.88 vs 0.80‒0.82; both P < .05). PMG (PM gauge) and L3SMG did not differ, whereas EMG (ESM gauge) or T12SMG and L3SMG did (AUC: 0.80‒0.82 vs 0.87‒0.88; all P < .05). L3SMI, L3SMD, T12SMG, EMG, and PMG showed no association with 1-year cancer-related mortality after adjusting for confounders; however, L3SMG [relative risk = 0.92 (0.85‒0.99); P = .023) was.
L3SMG covers all features of sarcopenia with more diagnostic value than other metrics, allowing a complete sarcopenia assessment with CT alone and not just in populations with cancer.
Zhang Y
,Zhang T
,Yin W
,Zhang L
,Xiang J
... -
《-》
Prognostic value of muscle measurement using the standardized phase of computed tomography in patients with advanced ovarian cancer.
The prognostic role of sarcopenia or myosteatosis is controversial in advanced-stage epithelial ovarian cancer (EOC). The phase of computed tomography (CT) could influence muscle measurement and confound its association with outcomes. This study evaluated the prognostic value of muscle measurement in patients with stage III EOC using a standardized phase of computed tomography.
Pretreatment CT images of 147 patients with stage III EOC were analyzed. All CT images were contrast-enhanced and acquired according to the standardized protocol. Skeletal muscle index (SMI) and radiodensity (SMD) were measured using CT images at the level of the third lumbar vertebra. The skeletal muscle gauge (SMG) was calculated by multiplying SMI and SMD. Harrell's concordance index (C-index) and time-dependent receiver operating characteristic curves were used to measure the predictive value of the models.
The median follow-up period was 37.5 mo. SMI, SMD, and SMG were independently associated with overall survival when adjusted for clinical variables. Adding SMG to the model including stage, residual tumor, and malignant ascites significantly improved C-indices (0.704 vs. 0.629; P < 0.001). Models including SMG had a superior C-index compared with models including SMI and SMD (0.704 vs. 0.668; P = 0.01). The SMG model achieved the highest area under the curve for 5-year overall survival prediction (0.619 for clinical model, 0.702 for SMI model, and 0.710 for SMG model).
Muscle measurements obtained from a standardized phase of CT images were associated with survival in advanced-stage EOC. The integration of SMI and SMD into SMG may improve prognostication and unify findings in future studies.
Huang CY
,Sun FJ
,Lee J
《-》
Comparison of CT derived body composition at the thoracic T4 and T12 with lumbar L3 vertebral levels and their utility in patients with rectal cancer.
Computed tomography (CT) derived body composition measurements of sarcopenia are an emerging form of prognostication in many disease processes. Although the L3 vertebral level is commonly used to measure skeletal muscle mass, other studies have suggested the utilisation of other segments. This study was performed to assess the variation and reproducibility of skeletal muscle mass at vertebral levels T4, T12 and L3 in pre-operative rectal cancer patients. If thoracic measurements were equivalent to those at L3, it will allow for body composition comparisons in a larger range of cancers where lumbar CT images are not routinely measured.
Patients with stage I - III rectal cancer, undergoing curative resection from 2010 - 2014, were assessed. CT based quantification of skeletal muscle was used to determine skeletal muscle cross sectional area (CSA) and skeletal muscle index (SMI). Systematic differences between the measurements at L3 with T4 and T12 vertebral levels were evaluated by percentile rank differences to assess distribution of differences and ordinary least product regression (OLP) to detect and distinguish fixed and proportional bias.
Eighty eligible adult patients were included. Distribution of differences between T12 SMI and L3 SMI were more marked than differences between T4 SMI and L3 SMI. There was no fix or proportional bias with T4 SMI, but proportional bias was detected with T12 SMI measurements. T4 CSA duplicate measurements had higher test-retest reliability: coefficient of repeatability was 34.10 cm2 for T4 CSA vs 76.00 cm2 for T12 CSA. Annotation time (minutes) with L3 as reference, the median difference was 0.85 for T4 measurements and -0.03 for T12 measurements. Thirty-seven patients (46%) had evidence of sarcopenia at the L3 vertebral level, with males exhibiting higher rates of sarcopenia. However, there was no association between sarcopenia and post-operative complications, recurrence or hospital LOS (length of stay) in patients undergoing curative resection.
Quantifying skeletal muscle mass at the T4 vertebral level is comparable to measures achieved at L3 in patients with rectal cancer, notwithstanding annotation time for T4 measurements are longer.
Arayne AA
,Gartrell R
,Qiao J
,Baird PN
,Yeung JM
... -
《BMC CANCER》
Percentile-based averaging and skeletal muscle gauge improve body composition analysis: validation at multiple vertebral levels.
Skeletal muscle metrics on computed tomography (CT) correlate with clinical and patient-reported outcomes. We hypothesize that aggregating skeletal muscle measurements from multiple vertebral levels and skeletal muscle gauge (SMG) better predict outcomes than skeletal muscle radioattenuation (SMRA) or -index (SMI) at a single vertebral level.
We performed a secondary analysis of prospectively collected clinical (overall survival, hospital readmission, time to unplanned hospital readmission or death, and readmission or death within 90 days) and patient-reported outcomes (physical and psychological symptom burden captured as Edmonton Symptom Assessment Scale and Patient Health Questionnaire) of patients with advanced cancer who experienced an unplanned admission to Massachusetts General Hospital from 2014 to 2016. First, we assessed the correlation of skeletal muscle cross-sectional area, SMRA, SMI, and SMG at one or more of the following thoracic (T) or lumbar (L) vertebral levels: T5, T8, T10, and L3 on CT scans obtained ≤50 days before index assessment. Second, we aggregated measurements across all available vertebral levels using percentile-based averaging (PBA) to create the average percentile. Third, we constructed one regression model adjusted for age, sex, sociodemographic factors, cancer type, body mass index, and intravenous contrast for each combination of (i) vertebral level and average percentile, (ii) muscle metrics (SMRA, SMI, & SMG), and (iii) clinical and patient-reported outcomes. Fourth, we compared the performance of vertebral levels and muscle metrics by ranking otherwise identical models by concordance statistic, number of included patients, coefficient of determination, and significance of muscle metric.
We included 846 patients (mean age: 63.5 ± 12.9 years, 50.5% males) with advanced cancer [predominantly gastrointestinal (32.9%) or lung (18.9%)]. The correlation of muscle measurements between vertebral levels ranged from 0.71 to 0.84 for SMRA and 0.67 to 0.81 for SMI. The correlation of individual levels with the average percentile was 0.90-0.93 for SMRA and 0.86-0.92 for SMI. The intrapatient correlation of SMRA with SMI was 0.21-0.40. PBA allowed for inclusion of 8-47% more patients than any single-level analysis. PBA outperformed single-level analyses across all comparisons with average ranks 2.6, 2.9, and 1.6 for concordance statistic, coefficient of determination, and significance (range 1-5, μ = 3), respectively. On average, SMG outperformed SMRA and SMI across outcomes and vertebral levels: the average rank of SMG was 1.4, 1.4, and 1.4 for concordance statistic, coefficient of determination, and significance (range 1-3, μ = 2), respectively.
Multivertebral level skeletal muscle analyses using PBA and SMG independently and additively outperform analyses using individual levels and SMRA or SMI.
Marquardt JP
,Roeland EJ
,Van Seventer EE
,Best TD
,Horick NK
,Nipp RD
,Fintelmann FJ
... -
《-》