Comparison of underivatized silica and zwitterionic sulfobetaine hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography stationary phases for global metabolomics of human plasma.

To increase metabolome coverage in global LC-MS metabolomics, often both reversed-phase liquid chromatography (RPLC) and hydrophilic-interaction liquid chromatography (HILIC) are implemented in parallel. However, there is a lack of consensus in the literature on the best HILIC stationary phase to employ for global metabolomics of human biological fluids. The objective of this study was to compare in detail the performance of two commonly employed HILIC phases: zwitterionic sulfobetaine ZIC-HILIC stationary phase and an underivatized silica HILIC stationary phase. During method development, the effect of salt concentration in the mobile phase was also investigated, and 5 mM ammonium acetate was selected. The stationary phases were evaluated using a mixture of 37 polar standards covering a range of logP values (-10 to 3.73), molecular weights (59-776 Da), charges (15 anions, 11 cations, and 11 neutral) as well as 17 lipid standards to understand phospholipid behaviour on the two stationary phases. The criteria used for the comparison included the quality of the chromatographic peak shape, adequate analyte retention, peak separation capability, and metabolite coverage. The zwitterionic ZIC-HILIC column provided better chromatographic performance over the silica stationary phase with 14 standards achieving good quality peaks compared to the 7 with the silica column. Only 2 standards were undetected with the ZIC-HILIC column compared to the 14 undetected with the silica column. In human plasma, 1966 and 1650 metabolites were observed on the ZIC-HILIC column in positive and negative electrospray ionization (ESI) respectively. On the silica HILIC column, 1773 and 2028 metabolites were observed in positive and negative ESI respectively, showing comparable performance of the two phases. Next, the effect of adding 10 mM ammonium phosphate to the samples to improve the analyte peak shape and metabolite coverage was investigated for both ZIC-HILIC and silica HILIC. In contrast with recently reported results for pZIC-HILIC, there was no clear evidence that ammonium phosphate addition was beneficial for human plasma samples. In conclusion, ZIC-HILIC provided better chromatographic performance for polar plasma metabolomics than underivatized silica in terms of chromatographic peak shape and chromatographic resolution, while maintaining comparable metabolite coverage. The addition of ammonium phosphate to human plasma was not beneficial for either of the two stationary phases.

Sonnenberg RA ，Naz S ，Cougnaud L ，Vuckovic D ... -  《-》

Optimized Analytical Procedures for the Untargeted Metabolomic Profiling of Human Urine and Plasma by Combining Hydrophilic Interaction (HILIC) and Reverse-Phase Liquid Chromatography (RPLC)-Mass Spectrometry.

Profiling of body fluids is crucial for monitoring and discovering metabolic markers of health and disease and for providing insights into human physiology. Since human urine and plasma each contain an extreme diversity of metabolites, a single liquid chromatographic system when coupled to mass spectrometry (MS) is not sufficient to achieve reasonable metabolome coverage. Hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography (HILIC) offers complementary information to reverse-phase liquid chromatography (RPLC) by retaining polar metabolites. With the objective of finding the optimal combined chromatographic solution to profile urine and plasma, we systematically investigated the performance of five HILIC columns with different chemistries operated at three different pH (acidic, neutral, basic) and five C18-silica RPLC columns. The zwitterionic column ZIC-HILIC operated at neutral pH provided optimal performance on a large set of hydrophilic metabolites. The RPLC columns Hypersil GOLD and Zorbax SB aq were proven to be best suited for the metabolic profiling of urine and plasma, respectively. Importantly, the optimized HILIC-MS method showed excellent intrabatch peak area reproducibility (CV < 12%) and good long-term interbatch (40 days) peak area reproducibility (CV < 22%) that were similar to those of RPLC-MS procedures. Finally, combining the optimal HILIC- and RPLC-MS approaches greatly expanded metabolome coverage with 44% and 108% new metabolic features detected compared with RPLC-MS alone for urine and plasma, respectively. The proposed combined LC-MS approaches improve the comprehensiveness of global metabolic profiling of body fluids and thus are valuable for monitoring and discovering metabolic changes associated with health and disease in clinical research studies.

Contrepois K ，Jiang L ，Snyder M 《-》

Development and application of a HILIC UHPLC-MS method for polar fecal metabolome profiling.

The fecal metabolome is a complex mixture of endogenous, microbial metabolites, and food derived compounds. Hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography (HILIC) enables the analysis of polar compounds, which is a valuable alternative to reversed-phase liquid chromatography in the field of metabolomics due to its ability to retain a greater portion of the polar metabolome. The objective of the study was to find the optimal chromatographic solution to perform non-targeted metabolomics of feces by means of HILIC ultra-high-pressure liquid chromatography mass spectrometry (UHPLC-Q-TOF-MS). The performance was systematically investigated analyzing a pooled fecal sample, and mixtures of 150 metabolites from different families, including for example amino acids, amines, indole derivatives, fatty acids and carbohydrates. Three different stationary phases (zwitterionic, amide and unbonded silica) were operated at three pH values (4.6, 6.8 and 9.0), and three salt gradient conditions (5-5, 5-10 and 5-25 mM ammonium acetate). Amide and zwitterionic stationary phases performed similarly at low pH, with highest number of detected standards, which increased by increasing the salt gradient. The amide column showed slightly better performance in terms of separation of isomers and peak widths and remarkably good performance at basic pH, with highest number of metabolite features in the non-targeted analysis. The zwitterionic column operated best in terms of number of detected standards, retention time distribution of standards and metabolite feature across whole chromatographic run. Thus, the zwitterionic column was proven to suit for non-targeted analysis of fecal samples, resulting in good coverage of especially amino acids and carbohydrates.

Sillner N ，Walker A ，Harrieder EM ，Schmitt-Kopplin P ，Witting M ... -  《-》

Evaluation of coverage, retention patterns, and selectivity of seven liquid chromatographic methods for metabolomics.

Wernisch S ，Pennathur S 《-》

Trace Phosphate Improves ZIC-pHILIC Peak Shape, Sensitivity, and Coverage for Untargeted Metabolomics.

Spalding JL ，Naser FJ ，Mahieu NG ，Johnson SL ，Patti GJ ... -  《-》